• Contact
  • Privacy Policy
Blacksonrise.com
DONATE
  • Home
    • Caribbean
    • African American
    • African
    • Australian
    • Papua New Guinea
  • Videos
    • Blacksonrise Interviews
    • Blacksonrise News
  • Ecourses
  • Herbs
  • Consultation
  • Login
    • LogOut
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • Caribbean
    • African American
    • African
    • Australian
    • Papua New Guinea
  • Videos
    • Blacksonrise Interviews
    • Blacksonrise News
  • Ecourses
  • Herbs
  • Consultation
  • Login
    • LogOut
No Result
View All Result
Blacksonrise.com
No Result
View All Result

‘A thinly veiled political lob’: Feds accuse Yale of discriminating against white and Asian students in admissions

blacksonrise by blacksonrise
August 14, 2020
in African American News
0
‘A thinly veiled political lob’: Feds accuse Yale of discriminating against white and Asian students in admissions
0
SHARES
339
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Department of Justice accused Yale University of discriminating against Asian-Americans and white applicants in its admissions process Thursday. 

The accusation is the latest flashpoint in a decades-long battle over the role of race in evaluating applicants for spots at top colleges, but it likely won’t immediately impact colleges’ approach to building their classes. It also comes amid years of pressure directed at top colleges to better serve Black, Hispanic and other students from underrepresented groups. 

The Department of Justice’s findings come two years after the agency opened an investigation into Yale’s admissions practices. In a four-page letter to the school, Eric Dreiband, an assistant attorney general in the Civil Rights Division, wrote that Yale “grants substantial, and often determinative, preferences based on race.” 

“Yale’s race discrimination imposes undue and unlawful penalties on racially-disfavored applicants, including in particular Asian American and White applicants,” the letter reads. 

The letter comes amid a slew of legal battles over the role of race in college admissions.  Lawsuits against Harvard University and the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill over the schools’ admissions practices are winding their way through the court system and could make their way to the Supreme Court. California legislators voted earlier this summer to put the question to voters of whether to repeal the state’s ban on affirmative action in the hiring of public employees, awarding public contracts and admissions to public universities in the state.

The DOJ’s findings are based on interpretations of earlier Supreme Court precedent and so they don’t change the landscape, at least not immediately, for how Yale or any other school will vet applicants, experts say. The letter is also in line with the Trump administration’s approach to the use of race in admissions; the DOJ filed a friend of the court brief earlier this year in support of the groups challenging Harvard’s admissions policies. 

If Yale and the agency can’t come to some sort of agreement in two weeks, the DOJ is prepared to file a lawsuit, the letter reads. 

“There’s a lot here that suggests this is a very thinly veiled political lob at a moment in time,” said Art Coleman, managing partner at Education Counsel, an education consulting firm. There’s not much evidence in the letter underlying the agency’s conclusion, Coleman, who worked in the Department of Education’s office of Civil Rights, said. Yale officials echoed that sentiment.

The school’s President, Peter Salovey, called the agency’s allegation “baseless,” in a statement. He said that the school has been cooperating with DOJ, but that the agency “concluded its investigation before reviewing and receiving all the information it has requested.”

“Given our university’s commitment to complying with federal law, I am dismayed that the DOJ inexplicably rushed to conclude its investigation without conducting a fully informed analysis, which would have shown that Yale’s practices absolutely comply with decades of Supreme Court precedent,” he said.

Supreme Court set a precedent on the role of race in admissions

That precedent allows colleges to consider race only as part of a broader goal of achieving educational diversity. In addition, schools can only weigh race as part of a holistic evaluation process that considers many factors — strategies such as quota systems are effectively banned.

One result of that approach is that the college admissions process, particularly at top schools, is “very opaque,” said Richard Ralph Banks, a professor at Stanford Law School. 

“It’s difficult to tell why people got in or didn’t get in,” he said. Typically, we expect transparency from public or public facing institutions, he said, “but here the Supreme Court flips that.” Instead of allowing schools to assign points or other clear value to particular criteria, the law requires that schools evaluate candidates holistically and share little about the weight they place on various factors, he said. 

“It tells the people who are doing the thing that’s transparent you can’t do that and it tells the people who are doing the thing that’s opaque, that’s what you must do,” said Banks “It’s kind of odd, but that’s the law.”  

He said it’s possible that colleges’ general counsels may be going over their admissions’ practices in the wake of Thursday’s letter and documenting clearly that “what we’re doing is consistent with what the Court said we can do.” That way, “if the Justice Department as we have right now is hostile to affirmative action and would try to initiate some enforcement action, the university is in a pretty good space.”

Letter offers a signal to legal strategy

The agency’s letter does offer a signal that DOJ is using a legal strategy similar to other litigants who have challenged affirmative action, Coleman said. He points to this statement from the letter as an indication: “The likelihood of admission for Asian American and White applicants who have similar academic credentials is significantly lower than for African American and Hispanic applicants to Yale College.” 

That framing, Coleman said, concludes “as a premise for the litigation that test scores and grades equal merit and we know definitively that’s not true. The whole notion of holistic review is about contextualization and the intersection of factors to make judgement.”

And indeed, the role of test scores and other more “traditional” admissions criteria, which often correspond with wealth and whiteness, has come under fire over the past several years as elite colleges face pressure to better serve Black, Hispanic and other students from groups that have historically been largely absent from these campuses. 

In Yale’s class of 2023, 20% of students receive a Pell grant, the money the government provides to low-income students to attend college. In that class, 11.8% of students are African-American, 25.9% are Asian-American and 49.3% are white. Roughly 12% of the class of 2023 — which had a 6.2% admissions rate — have a legacy affiliation. 

The college admissions scandal last year highlighted the advantages white, wealthy and well-connected students often have in the admissions process. Inequities in kindergarten through 12th grade schooling as well as a dearth of access to expensive test preparation courses and extracurricular activities have meant that well-resourced schools, like Yale, tend to serve a relatively small percentage of the nation’s poorest students. 

At the same time, schools that serve a wider swath of Black, Hispanic and low-income students, often have less money at their disposal to get these students to and through college. The inequity could be exacerbated by the coronavirus pandemic, as many colleges worry about a drop off in enrollment — a metric that is key to their financial health. 

The debate over Yale’s admissions policy presents a sort of “counterpoint of that,” Banks said. The case “just kind of shows how sought after they are.” 

Credit: Source link

Previous Post

ICE Detention Center Officials Indiscriminately Tear Gassed Asylum-Seekers, Complaints Say

Next Post

Caribbean Life: Brooklyn Edition: August 14, 2020

Next Post
Caribbean Life: Brooklyn Edition: August 14, 2020

Caribbean Life: Brooklyn Edition: August 14, 2020

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT

HOT Updates

African American Michigan: Rock the Vote, suppressing Black votes | News, Sports, Jobs
African American News

Governor Whitmer announces appointments to Bipartisan Protect Michigan Commission | News, Sports, Jobs

January 27, 2021
Four CEOs Speak On Racial Inequalities In Corporate America And How To Change
African American Business

Four CEOs Speak On Racial Inequalities In Corporate America And How To Change

January 20, 2021
Kumasi lawyer links country’s under-development to bad leadership
Africa Business

Kumasi lawyer links country’s under-development to bad leadership

January 23, 2021
Gladys Berejiklian defends January 26 as date to mark Australia Day
Aboriginal Australia News

Gladys Berejiklian defends January 26 as date to mark Australia Day

January 25, 2021
Residents in KC metro watch inauguration, talk expectations for new administration
African American News

Residents in KC metro watch inauguration, talk expectations for new administration

January 21, 2021
Two grabbed for child trafficking in Tatale
African News

Two grabbed for child trafficking in Tatale

January 27, 2021
Eskom not affected by Cyclone Eloise – SABC News
Africa Business

Eskom not affected by Cyclone Eloise – SABC News

January 25, 2021
In U.K., Concern Grows Over Vaccine Hesitancy Among Minority Groups
African American News

In U.K., Concern Grows Over Vaccine Hesitancy Among Minority Groups

January 25, 2021
WHPHA Face Medicine Shortage Again – EMTV Online
Papua New Guinea News

WHPHA Face Medicine Shortage Again – EMTV Online

January 26, 2021
People moves: Kina Bank, Mayur Resources, Newcrest Mining and Pacific Trade Invest
Papua New Guinea Business

People moves: ExxonMobil, NDB, NBPOL, Twinza, Minister for Foreign Affairs, Pacific Community, Capital Insurance Group, Papua New Guinea Cocoa Board, Kumul Telikom Holdings

January 26, 2021
No increase in cooking gas prices
Caribbean Business

No increase in cooking gas prices

January 23, 2021
Indigenous Rappers Warn Australians of COVID-19 Threat | Voice of America
Aboriginal Australia News

Australia Contemplates Controversy Surrounding Its National Day | Voice of America

January 23, 2021
86-Year-Old Accountant Shares Powerful Success Tips 
African American Business

86-Year-Old Accountant Shares Powerful Success Tips 

January 25, 2021
Meet The 26-Year-Old Who Paid Off $23,000 Debt in 12 Months
African American Business

Meet The 26-Year-Old Who Paid Off $23,000 Debt in 12 Months

January 23, 2021
A Democratic Rep. Is Seeking To Have Rudy Giuliani Disbarred
African American Business

Dominion Voting Systems Files $1B Defamation Suit Against Rudy Giuliani

January 26, 2021
Abuse survivor Grace Tame named Australian of the Year
Aboriginal Australia News

Abuse survivor Grace Tame named Australian of the Year

January 25, 2021
North Korean diplomat defects to South Korea
Aboriginal Australia News

North Korean diplomat defects to South Korea

January 26, 2021
19 Aboriginal Owned Businesses To Support This Invasion Day
Aboriginal Australia Business

19 Aboriginal Owned Businesses To Support This Invasion Day

January 24, 2021
Joe Biden Repeals Donald Trump’s Transgender Military Ban
Afro Latino News

Joe Biden Repeals Donald Trump’s Transgender Military Ban

January 25, 2021
WakeMed COVID-19 vaccine clinic focuses on underserved communities
African American News

WakeMed COVID-19 vaccine clinic focuses on underserved communities

January 25, 2021

BlackSonRise.com is an online news portal which aims to provide Caribbean News, African News, Business and much more stuff like that. Feel free to get in touch with us!

Follow us on social media:

Recent News

  • How might media policy influence the health of diverse communities?
  • ‘Travel ban imposed by US government will not affect business’ – SABC News
  • Africa: Gambia Pair With Ghana in Africa U-20 Youth Championship

Subscribe NOW

Loading
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

© 2019 Blacksonrise.com is an online news, e-learning, and business website that caters to the global black community.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • Caribbean
    • African American
    • African
    • Australian
    • Papua New Guinea
  • Videos
    • Blacksonrise Interviews
    • Blacksonrise News
  • Ecourses
  • Herbs
  • Consultation
  • Login
    • LogOut

© 2019 Blacksonrise.com is an online news, e-learning, and business website that caters to the global black community.

USD $
  • USD USD $
  • EUR EUR €
  • GBP GBP £