• Contact
  • Privacy Policy
Blacksonrise.com
DONATE
  • Home
    • Caribbean
    • African American
    • African
    • Australian
    • Papua New Guinea
  • Videos
    • Blacksonrise Interviews
    • Blacksonrise News
  • Ecourses
  • Herbs
  • Consultation
  • Login
    • LogOut
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • Caribbean
    • African American
    • African
    • Australian
    • Papua New Guinea
  • Videos
    • Blacksonrise Interviews
    • Blacksonrise News
  • Ecourses
  • Herbs
  • Consultation
  • Login
    • LogOut
No Result
View All Result
Blacksonrise.com
No Result
View All Result

Morrison closes the books on black disadvantage | Mandurah Mail

blacksonrise by blacksonrise
February 14, 2020
in Aboriginal Australia News
0
Morrison closes the books on black disadvantage | Mandurah Mail
0
SHARES
4
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The annual February Closing the Gap statement by the prime minister of the day is becoming one of the major Caucasian political festivals, a generally bipartisan affair at which politicians express regret to each other about the general lack of significant progress in Aboriginal advancement, then prepare the ground for much the same regress over the year ahead. The speeches generally acknowledge key deficiencies in the program – not least of top-down decision-making, and a failure to involve Aboriginal people at the community level in planning, delivering and evaluating programs.

Accounting for Indigenous disadvantage has become a permanent feature of our political system – with little change. Picture: Shutterstock

They promise that it will be different in future, and there will be consultation between the various groups of people failing to deliver about ways of setting more “realistic – generally less onerous” goals. The very bureaucracy and politicking involved in the process is underlined by the promise of more discussions between prime ministers, premiers and chief ministers at forthcoming meetings of COAG (the council of Australian governments) and consultations and non-binding discussions with representatives of peak groups of Aboriginal organisations. These were, ironically, set up at about the time the process of emasculation and reduction (by Commonwealth officials) of the number of on-the-ground community organisations was completed.

Whole forests which did not burn during bushfire season have been felled for the numerous Closing the Gap reports issued each year – many duplicating each other’s efforts. These chronicle various forms of Aboriginal disadvantage. Some show some slight improvement in last year’s raw figures, but are gloomy because improvement in non-Aboriginal statistics for the same thing have led to the chasm having actually increased. Others record raw figures going backwards.

A few show some agonising progress, and are seized on as evidence that a program is “on track” to bring the average Aboriginal situation to be much the same as the non-Aboriginal situation. A vast army of economists, statisticians, and bureaucrats, mostly non-Indigenous, are engaged in counting black bums on seats, in jobs or in (or not in) coffins; others are weighing, measuring, and weighting returns, or are rationalising the outcomes. Scott Morrison thinks the matters chosen for the report are too negative, and wants one with more positive news, in part because he is not as despondent about progress as most other observers, particularly those without an axe to grind.

A few years ago, I calculated that government at every level was spending roughly $250,000 a year on every Aboriginal family. This was a sum great enough for every Aboriginal child to attend a top private boarding school, and have the families driving Range Rovers and regularly dining on pheasant under glass.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison in Parliament on Thursday. Picture: Dion Georgopoulos

Prime Minister Scott Morrison in Parliament on Thursday. Picture: Dion Georgopoulos

Alas, this spending rarely actually reached the families – on average only about $25,000 a family did. The greater proportion – about 90 per cent, indeed – never reached an Aboriginal community, an Aboriginal organisation or created any sort of multiplier effect in a local economy. It was going to bureaucrats, accountants, economists, statisticians, Canberra-based consultancy firms telling governments just what they wanted to hear, doctors, nurses, lawyers, teachers, cops and grader drivers – as well as to largely white tradesmen, contractors and rent-seekers. It was true that there was an increasing proportion of people of Indigenous background among the provider groups, but most were not of the communities they were there to assist.

Advertisements

The disparity of income between the provider industry and those being “serviced” by it was, of course, relentlessly policed by an army of government welfare officers focused on coercing generally pointless behaviour as a form of dancing for the charity dispensed. Dehumanised schemes regularly struck off (at among the highest rates in Australia) some of the poorest people in the country from one form or another of welfare benefits for failure to meet requirements written in Canberra and bearing no relationship with local conditions. In many communities, particularly the most remote and most disadvantaged communities, the lack of choice, and the lack of personal autonomy, is reinforced by the coerced imposition of the BasicsCard – from which one cannot obtain cash, let alone engage in vicious practices such as smoking or drinking alcohol.

This is, no doubt, the sort of thing that Scott Morrison was thinking of last week in his melancholy litany of why things are so bad. Like most such speeches, it veered between addressing and apologising to Indigenous people, and addressing non-Indigenous Australians with reminders of how we had been so beastly, and had never understood Aboriginal people and what they wanted, at least until he had been blinded by his insights and understanding.

“We all have, in our own way, sought to grapple with the consequences of two-and-a-quarter centuries of Indigenous disempowerment,” he said. Just what was his own way may be an on-water matter.

Many of the same national Aboriginal voices are the ones that he is consciously ignoring over the Uluru Statement.

“What I know is that to rob a person of their right to take responsibility for themselves; to strip them of responsibility and capability to direct their own futures; to make them dependent – this is to deny them of their liberty, and slowly that person will wither before your eyes.

“That’s what we did to our First Nations people – and mostly, we didn’t even know we were doing it. We thought we were helping when we replaced independence with welfare.

“This must change. We must restore the right to take responsibility. The right to make decisions. The right to step up. The opportunity to own and create Australians’ own futures.

“It must be accompanied by a willingness to push decisions down to the people who are closest to them. Where the problems are, and where the consequences of decisions are experienced.

“That is what we must do.”

In a vague sort of way he means it, of course. It’s a matter of marketing, if not always of substance. These days, a prime minister must be statesmanlike on matters of national shame (other than climate change action and boat people, of course).

Just as Kevin Rudd – who established the Closing the Gap program, and with objective measures of achievement – meant it when he said similar things. He didn’t change anything about Aboriginal government. Indeed, under him it became more coercive and more disempowering.

Likewise with Julia Gillard, whose fellow feeling with the victims and understanding of their plight was self-evident. And with Tony Abbott, who wanted to be the prime minister for Indigenous Australians, even as he slashed budgets designed for narrowing the gaps. And Malcolm Turnbull, as good at breast-beating as any of his predecessors. Or his successor.

Peter Broelman's view.

Peter Broelman’s view.

They all understand the problem. They all mean their plans to win Aboriginal people over to enthusiastic adoption of the accumulated wisdom of the white tribes, after it has been translated into umpteen Indigenous languages, engaged and consulted “on the ground” in communities by professional facilitators who have undergone cultural training programs, by methods vouched for by external auditors of that sort of thing, then certified by a task force from the Big Four accountancy firms (the latter being well-known for their expertise and experience in Indigenous matters, but also for their assiduousness in settling, before and after their independent reviews, that the report is exactly what the minister wants, and that it contains “no unpleasant surprises”).

It was always thus, and probably always will be. Scott Morrison means to stop it, by golly. He really really means it this time. Just as did all of his predecessors, to no effect. Morrison, or his department under his loyal secretary Phil Gaetjens, will probably establish a task force to make it all happen, in the process co-opting what passes for formal national Indigenous consulters to show his seriousness of intention and his goodwill. That will be handy, down the track, for socialising the blame for further failure.

Many of the same national Aboriginal voices are the ones that he is consciously ignoring over the Uluru Statement, the question of recognising Indigenous folk in the Australian constitution, and the question of an Aboriginal “voice” in our legislative and executive government. He does not buy their recommendations, or the priorities they attach to them.

It is true that his Minister for Indigenous Affairs is trying, patiently, to gather something from the fragments of explicit Coalition rejection; something which can be put to a referendum, perhaps in the form of legislation rather than constitutional change.

On gap-closing, however, it is all about partnership and mutual respect – as well, probably, as convenient amnesia, and yet another round of suspending cynicism in the hope against hope that it is not just marketing palaver.

But it is all now, apparently, about working together. At the federal, state and local government level. With a new piece of paper agreed to last year at COAG. And not just between different agencies of Indigenous affairs, but “whole governments, at every point of contact”.

“Every minister in my government is a minister for Indigenous Australians,” Morrison said. “And the Minister for Indigenous Australians is the first amongst equals in this cause.

“More importantly, for governments to work with local communities. In partnership with the Coalition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peaks – known as the Coalition of Peaks, and with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.

“We’re making that commitment real. This is what our Closing the Gap refresh is about. It’s what all governments agreed to at COAG a little over a year ago.

“It’s what Aborigines and Torres Strait Islander people have been saying for a long time. They want a partnership where we listen, work together, and decide together how future policies are developed – especially at a regional and local level. A partnership that respects their expertise and acknowledges their place as the First Nations people of this continent.”

Heavens, why has no one had these blinding insights before?


Credit: Source link

Previous Post

Black Former PNC Bank Employee Wins $2.4M Sexual Harassment Judgement Against Bank

Next Post

Clarity needed on sovereign wealth fund: Chief Economist - SABC News

Next Post
Clarity needed on sovereign wealth fund: Chief Economist – SABC News

Clarity needed on sovereign wealth fund: Chief Economist - SABC News

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT

HOT Updates

Tobago schools receive digital devices from THA
Caribbean Business

Tobago schools receive digital devices from THA

January 11, 2021
Apple, Hyundai set to agree electric car tie-up – SABC News
Africa Business

Apple, Hyundai set to agree electric car tie-up – SABC News

January 11, 2021
Nike Invests $500K in Black Women Through Black Girl Ventures
African American Business

Nike Invests $500K in Black Women Through Black Girl Ventures

January 9, 2021
Caribbean Life: Queens Edition: January 15, 2021
Caribbean News

Caribbean Life: Queens Edition: January 15, 2021

January 15, 2021
Adovactes push to get vaccines on Charleston’s west side
African American News

Adovactes push to get vaccines on Charleston’s west side

January 10, 2021
How to save a language when its people disappear
Aboriginal Australia News

How to save a language when its people disappear

January 13, 2021
Cori Bush Responds to Terror Attack on Capitol Hill: ‘Must Face Consequences’
African American Business

Cori Bush Responds to Terror Attack on Capitol Hill: ‘Must Face Consequences’

January 10, 2021
Rediscovering our place in nature – BC Local News
Aboriginal Australia News

Rediscovering our place in nature – BC Local News

January 12, 2021
Molefe to testify at State Capture Inquiry – SABC News
Africa Business

Molefe to testify at State Capture Inquiry – SABC News

January 15, 2021
Wall Street drops as big banks fall after results – SABC News
Africa Business

Wall Street drops as big banks fall after results – SABC News

January 15, 2021
Awesome Online Events Happening This Week In Southern California: Jan. 11
African American News

Awesome Online Events Happening This Week In Southern California: Jan. 11

January 14, 2021
African American News

(BPRW) PLAYWRIGHT/SONGWRITER NOVEMBER CHRISTINE RE-RELEASES A TRIBUTE TO CHANGE VIDEO TO DRAW ATTENTION TO BLM AND CELEBRATE THE MEMORY OF MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. | Press releases

January 14, 2021
Esteemed Tuskegee Airmen Theodore Lumpkin Dies From COVID-19
African American Business

Esteemed Tuskegee Airmen Theodore Lumpkin Dies From COVID-19

January 10, 2021
BEMAWU threatens strike action at the SABC – SABC News
Africa Business

BEMAWU threatens strike action at the SABC – SABC News

January 14, 2021
2021 Final SP Hunters Squad Named – EMTV Online
Papua New Guinea News

2021 Final SP Hunters Squad Named – EMTV Online

January 11, 2021
2020 in review: A torrid year like no other
Aboriginal Australia News

2020 in review: A torrid year like no other

January 12, 2021
Aboriginal Australia News

Human Rights Watch warns US Capitol attack should be ‘wake-up call’ for Australia | Far right

January 13, 2021
Why AMResorts Is Bullish on Curacao and Cozumel
Caribbean News

Why AMResorts Is Bullish on Curacao and Cozumel

January 10, 2021
Hilton Hotel in Durban closes its doors temporarily – SABC News
Africa Business

Hilton Hotel in Durban closes its doors temporarily – SABC News

January 11, 2021
154,000 Black Women Left The Workforce In December Alone
Afro Latino News

154,000 Black Women Left The Workforce In December Alone

January 12, 2021

BlackSonRise.com is an online news portal which aims to provide Caribbean News, African News, Business and much more stuff like that. Feel free to get in touch with us!

Follow us on social media:

Recent News

  • Prominent Leaders Voice Strong Support for Attorney General James’ Lawsuit Against NYPD – African American News Today
  • Lawsuit filed for ‘TT’ children in ISIS refugee camps
  • Questions of privilege, mythology and identity

Subscribe NOW

Loading
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

© 2019 Blacksonrise.com is an online news, e-learning, and business website that caters to the global black community.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • Caribbean
    • African American
    • African
    • Australian
    • Papua New Guinea
  • Videos
    • Blacksonrise Interviews
    • Blacksonrise News
  • Ecourses
  • Herbs
  • Consultation
  • Login
    • LogOut

© 2019 Blacksonrise.com is an online news, e-learning, and business website that caters to the global black community.

USD $
  • USD USD $
  • EUR EUR €
  • GBP GBP £